One of the biggest challenges I find is making student presentations effective, so again, my choice of second #TLAB13 workshop picked itself. Rosie McColl, Deputy Head of English at Berkhamsted School, led a workshop which posed the question: can students be effective teachers?
Rosie had endeavoured to fix the age-old problem of ineffective group presentations. I thoroughly enjoyed Rosie’s workshop as it contained ‘real’ (video) examples of her action-research.
We saw examples of student vox pops on the problems of presentations:
- they enjoy the research but don’t like the feedback if it isn’t engaging, detailed or the presenter(s) is nervous.
- if all class are doing the same topic, fine but if not, we only really learn our own topic.
- it’s nice to hear other voices and views though.
and the one that surprised me the most:
- I don’t trust other pupils’ research – teachers should validate content.
This was backed up eloquently by several pupils in the audience (and whoever’s school they were from, they were a credit to you) who echoed much of what Rosie’s videoed pupils had shared.
So, what can be done to improve on this?
We’ve all come across research that says we learn best when we teach others, so equipping our pupils to do this effectively must be the holy grail.
Rosie’s approach was simple but effective.
Her year 10 boys were looking at war poetry. They needed to makes links and connections. The class was split into groups and all were given a selection of unseen texts, poetry and prose. Half the groups were tasked with presenting their findings via the traditional method of ‘telling’ the audience. The other half were told only to use questions when presenting their findings.
(Some time had been spent on effective question formulation prior to splitting into the groups, so all pupils had come up with some ‘good’ questions or question stems to aid with their discussions.)
We saw videos of the pupils feeding back. The ‘tellers’ were predictably dull with a fairly dis-engaged audience. The ‘questioners’ were much more engaging. Both audiences, classroom and conference, were paying attention, considering responses, involved.
Rosie said she was simply offering one idea of how to make pupils better teachers, she wasn’t claiming it was the best or only solution.
Sometimes though, it’s the simple ideas which are the best.
Pupils as questioners and not tellers: there’s my year 12 lessons planned for the next week or so!
(Oh and if you’re not already, then get following Rosie on Twitter: @rosiemccoll)